- Open Access
Influence of milling pH and storage on quality characteristics, mineral and fatty acid profile of buffalo Mozzarella cheese
Lipids in Health and Diseasevolume 18, Article number: 33 (2019)
Currently, cheese fat is a major component of human diet due to change in eating habits. It contains a number of health destroying as well as health promoting fatty acids. Bovine milk cheese fatty acid composition is regulating by many factors. These may be breed of animal, animal health condition like mastitis and stage of lactation. It also differs with feed and dietary fat intake and seasons. Many studies demonstrated physicochemical, textural and sensory characteristics of Mozzarella cheese with variation in technological process but no literature found about the fatty acid profile and potential influence of milling pH on the fatty acid composition of buffalo Mozzarella cheese.
Buffalo Mozzarella cheeses were manufactured at 5.2, 5.1, 5.0, 4.9 and 4.8 milling pH, vacuum packaged and stored at 4 °C and analyzed for quality characteristics, mineral composition and fatty acid profile on days 1, 45, and 90. Results were analyzed by ANOVA according to complete randomized design.
This study evaluated the effect of milling pH on chemical composition, mineral and fatty acid profile of buffalo Mozzarella cheese. Experimentally induced milling pH differences persisted and significantly affected chemical composition during first day of manufacturing but have no effect on fatty acid profile of cheese. However, storage effects significantly on chemical composition and fatty acid profile of cheese. Decreasing milling pH from 5.2–4.9 resulted in decrease in moisture content of cheese. As a result of changes in milling pH, all the cheeses experienced a significant loss in protein content. In contrast to protein content, fat content of cheese increases with decreasing milling pH. Ash contents of cheese decreased with decreasing milling pH. The level of calcium decreases from 77.82 mg/g to 69.1 mg/g with decreasing milling pH while there is no clear trend observed for potassium and sodium during change in milling pH. Saturated fatty acids presented higher concentrations reaching values of about 71.38 g/100 g throughout storage while monounsaturated fatty acids decreases with storage from 26.72 to 22.06 g/100 g. On the other hand, total polyunsaturated fatty acids exhibited lower concentrations than total monounsaturated fatty acids reaching values of 3.2 g/100 g and its value also decreased with ripening and reached to 1.6 g/100 g. Concentration of C18:1 t10–11 was observed 1.89% in freshly prepared cheese. Milling pH did not influence C18:1 t10–11 concentration but storage days significantly (p < 0.05) decreased its concentration.
In modern era, Mozzarella cheese is major source of dietary fatty acids. The study demonstrated that Mozzarella cheese is a rich source of saturated fatty acids that has detrimental effect on health but it is also observed that it is also a major source of essential fatty acids that has beneficial impact on health. It is concluded that technological conditions like milling pH minimally influence cheese fatty acid profile but after manufacturing treatments and conditions like packaging and storage greatly influence fatty acid profile of cheese. It was concluded that cheese may get oxidized if it is packed in inappropriate packaging material that have reduced air barrier resistance. Moreover, cheese storage under light may also become oxidized which is also harmful for health.
Worldwide, consumer’s attention has been started to be focused on foods that have well specified health impacts. One of the important component of food that concerns more to consumer’s health is the fatty acid profile of food which includes short, intermediate and long chain fatty acids . Recent advices for a good diet however, recommends less consumption of dairy fat, because of its saturated fatty acids, which have hypercholesterolemic effect. But dairy fat is also important due to presence of unsaturated fatty acids which is helpful in reducing blood cholesterol content and also provide protection against cancer and cardiovascular diseases .Changing lifestyle, eating habits and use of innovative technology in processing of Mozzarella cheese demands tailor made characteristics of this cheese. Therefore, cheese manufacturer are producing cheese that is well suiting to consumers requirements. In this aspect, increase in interest of consumers to know the fatty acid (FA) composition of cheese is continuously increasing, as certain unsaturated FA are recognized as bioactive substances . Mozzarella cheese has become one of the dominant cheese varieties all over the world due to its primary utilization in pizza preparation. Buffalo milk is most demanded for Mozzarella due to its high fat and presence of essential fatty acids . Pakistan is the 5th largest milk producer of the world and ‘Black Gold of Asia’ commonly known as buffalo milk donate a major part in total milk production of Pakistan and this black gold is very suitable for the production of mozzarella cheese .
Dairy fat is a vital component of human diet owing to their essential functions perform in to the body. Milk fat triacylglycerol are created from more than 400 types of fatty .The saturated and unsaturated fatty acids in milk accounts for about 70 and 27% by weight . While, 2.7% of the fatty acids occur in Trans form. Many factors are associated with the variation in the amount and fatty acid composition of bovine milk lipids . They may be of animal origin, i.e. related to genetics (breed and selection), stage of lactation, mastitis and ruminal fermentation, or they may be feed-related factors, i.e. related to fiber and energy intake, dietary fats, and seasonal and regional effects. In most of countries many customers are happy to pay more for handmade cheese as compared to cheese made on industrial scale. As there is a general adverse nutritional image that handmade cheese has attractive flavor and texture. But with a rising number of customers who are more careful about their food selections, artisanal cheese can’t be surpassed. Although milling pH processing step exist in both artisanal and industrial processing but artisanal producers get benefit of milk quality that differs with season and feed of animal. The animal feed affect the quality of cheese as different grazing pastures gives different fatty acid profile and flavor of cheese . Artisanal cheesemakers change manufacturing schedule of different cheese varieties or change processing steps with time of year. It is concluded that artisanal cheese quality not solely depends on method of manufacturing but other parameters also influence cheese quality. Various researches indicating milk processing conditions that affect fatty acid profile of developed product. As the effects of processing conditions like heating, cooking, storage and aging on the fatty acid profile of milk fat and dairy products have often been deliberated disputed. Ha et al.  stated higher Conjugate Linoleic Acid (CLA) contents in cheese fat as compared to milk fat. Some scientist observed no change on the fatty acid composition of cheeses including Pecorino Romano cheese, blue cheese, Swiss cheese, Emmental cheese and Ricotta cheese [11, 12].In one study it is stated that processing, such as heating, can change the CLA isomer distribution in dairy products while the total CLA content is unchanged by conventional processing . Lin et al.  observed significantly lower CLA content in vacuum packed cheese as compared to canned cheese. They also found minor influence of milling pH and antioxidant on fatty acid composition of Cheddar cheese. Gürsoy et al.  examined 30 commercial Turkish hard and soft cheeses and detected higher CLA content in aged hard cheeses. Some conditions other than processing may also influence fatty acid profile of cheese like diet of animal and season. Santillo et al.  studied the influence of dietary supplementation of flax seed on the fatty acid profile of milk and Cacioricotta cheese from Italian Simmental cows and concluded that long chain fatty acids particularly linolenic acid was found to be higher in cheese made from milk of cows fed with flaxseed. Seasonal variation also influence the fatty acid profile of cheese as it is directly or indirectly related to the diet of the animal. Pasture quality varies with the change in season .These contradictory reports about the fatty acid profile of cheeses do not countenance decisive remarks to be drawn. Modern dietary guidelines recommend knowing the fatty acid profile of each food item before consuming. Mozzarella cheese milling pH (The pH at which cheese is milled into small pieces and is ready for pasta filata process) is an important step that affect all functional and sensory characteristics of cheese. Formation of curd chips depends on milling pH which ultimately influence cheese composition and functional characteristics. Guinee et al.  studied that curd disintegrate at 5.75 milling pH. They found that curd will form its proper texture at 5.3 milling pH in case of cheddar cheese. Gulzar et al.  found that buffalo Mozzarella cheese exhibit more stretch properties at 4.9 milling pH. At higher milling pH curd do not stretch and disintegrate in hot water during pasta filata process and loses of fat occurs. Although many reports about influence of milling pH on physicochemical and functional characteristics of Mozzarella cheese have been given by several workers but, little literature found about the fatty acids profile and potential influence of milling pH on the fatty acid composition of buffalo Mozzarella cheese. In this study, we thus concentrated on the fatty acid composition of buffalo Mozzarella cheese at various milling pH.
Materials and methods
Heat stretched semi-soft “Mozzarella” cheese samples was made using raw milk exclusively from buffalo milk procured from Dairy Animals Training and Research Center University of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, Lahore. For cheese making, partially skimmed (0.9 casein to fat ratio) pasteurized buffalo milk was inoculated and coagulated with thermophilic starter at 37 °C and bovine rennet respectively. Starter culture and rennet take 1 h and 50 min to develop curd and pH of 6.4. The curd is cut with knife into 3–4 mm curd particles. The curd-whey mixture is heated to 37–42 °C till 6.2 pH for whey removal. This curd-whey heating process continue for 30 min. The curd is placed for cheddaring process until 5.2, 5.1, 5.0, 4.9 and 4.8 milling pH resulted five treatment samples (M5.2, M5.1, M5.0, M4.9 and M 4.8). Cheddaring process last for 1 h and 10 min to develop required pH. The milled cheese was heat stretched at 94 °C and vacuum packed for a storage period of 90 days in polyethylene nylon food vacuum plastic bags of 100 μm thickness.
Sodium potassium and calcium contents were determined using flame photometer as described by .
Fatty acid analysis
The fatty acid methyl esters were prepared by trans-esterification with potassium hydroxide according to method of ISO 5509:2000E . The injected volume was 1 μL. Each sample was analyzed three times. Fatty acid profile of Mozzarella cheese including CLA was determined on GC-MS (Agilent Technologies, Model 7890-B) using SP-2560 fused silica capillary column (60 m long, 0.25 mm internal diameter, 0.25um phase thickness) on a flame ionization detector. Injection volume was 1 1 μL, the temperature program and operating conditions were as: injector and detector temperature 200 and 250 °C; carrier gas helium at 1.2 ml/min, hydrogen 4 ml/min and oxygen 40 ml/min, in a split mode, the column was maintained at 50 °C for 1 min then ramped at 10 °C/min to 220 °C and finally 3 min at 250 °C. Fatty acids were identified and quantified by FAME-37 standard (Sigma Aldrich, USA).
Sensory characteristics of Mozzarella cheese were determined in a well ventilated and illuminated sensory evaluation laboratory. Panel of ten trained judges were asked to adjudge color, appearance, texture) by the method .
Every treatment was run in triplicate, experiment was planned in a Completely Randomized Design (CRD) and data were analyzed by two way analysis of variance and significant difference among the treatments was determined by Duncan Multiple Range Test using SAS 9.1 software .
Results and discussions
Physicochemical analysis of buffalo Milk and cheese
The means of the physicochemical parameters (fat, protein, pH, acidity, total solids and calcium content) in buffalo milk were found (6.65, 4.5%, 6.6, 0.12, 12.12% and 1.7 mg/g) respectively. While, the physicochemical analysis of cheeses are given in Table 1.
The changes in levels of calcium, potassium and sodium in cheese made with milling pH of 5.2, 5.1, 5.0, 4.9 and 4.8 during 90 days of storage are shown in Table 2.
Fatty acid profile of cheese
Statistical results indicated that milling pH effects non-significantly while ripening affects significantly on fatty acid profile of Mozzarella cheese. Table 3 showed the saturated (SFA), monounsaturated (MUFA) and polyunsaturated (PUFA) fatty acid profiles of Mozzarella cheese prepared at various milling pH. SFA presented higher concentrations than total MUFA reaching values of 71.38 and 26.7 g/100 g lipids (Table 3), respectively, at 1st day. On the other hand, total PUFA exhibited lower concentrations than total MUFA reaching values of 3.2 g/100 g lipids at first day (Table 3). Saturated fatty acids presented higher concentrations reaching values of about 71.38 g/100 g throughout storage while monounsaturated fatty acids decreases with storage from 26.72 to 22.06 g/100 g. On the other hand, total polyunsaturated fatty acids exhibited lower concentrations than total monounsaturated fatty acids reaching values of 3.2 g/100 g and its value also decreased with ripening and reached to 1.6 g/100 g. The amount of CLA (C18:1 t10–11) was found 1.89% in freshly prepared cheese. Milling pH has no influence C18:1 t10–11 concentration but storage period significantly (P < 0.05) decreased its concentration.
Color change in mozzarella cheese
The whiteness of cheese samples decreased significantly (P < 0.05) with milling pH and storage as indicated from Table 4.
Appearance is a quick indication of cheese quality which indicates surface consistency and fusion of cheese shreds after cooking. The results of appearance scores are shown in Table 4. Appearance scores of cheese samples generally increased with decreasing milling pH however appearance scores decreases with storage.
With respect to hardness; cheese showed less compression force with decreasing milling pH Table 4. Maximum force was observed at 5.2 pH while lowest found at 4.8.
The results demonstrated that decreasing milling pH from 5.2–4.9 resulted in decrease in moisture content of cheese. It is because of low pH which tends to unstable the protein network which releases more moisture .With reducing milling pH from 5.2 to 4.9 it was seen that starter cultures caused to increase titratable acidity form 0.70 to 1.78 which in turn increase the amount of whey separation . As a result of the changes of the milling pH, all the cheeses experienced a significant loss in protein content. This was detected as a continuous decrease in whey level throughout cheddaring period which is a rich source of protein . In contrast to protein content, fat content of cheese increases with decreasing milling pH. It might be due to more time taken to stretch the cheese which loses the fat contents of cheese . Buffalo mozzarella cheese does not stretch at higher milling pH (from 5.2 to 5.0) which increases fat loses during stretching. Ash contents of cheese decreased with decreasing milling pH. It is due to development of acid that solubilize the micellar calcium phosphate and acting as a vehicle to expel minerals in whey . The level of calcium decreases with decreasing milling pH while there is no clear trend observed for potassium and sodium during change in milling pH. The effect of milling pH on drainage affects calcium as the majority of the non-micellar calcium is lost in the whey. The changing of the pH at milling influences the level of calcium lost in the whey . Storage affects minerals composition non- significantly (P > 0.05).
Processing condition (milling pH) has no effect on the fatty acid profile of Mozzarella cheese. During the storage period of 90 days, concentration of unsaturated fatty acids decreased and saturated fatty acids increased on percentage basis. Literature also support the findings of this investigation, amount of unsaturated fatty acids decreased in the long term storage of cheddar cheese . Fatty acid profile of fresh and ripened cheddar cheese is different, also confirmed by the . Concentration of C18:1 t10–11in freshly prepared Mozzarella cheese was 1.89%. Milling pH had no effect on the concentration of C18:1 t10–11, storage up to 45 days had a non-significant effect, after 90 days of storage of Mozzarella cheese, concentration of C18:1 t10–11in was significantly lower than the fresh cheese. Storage duration had a significant effect on concentration of conjugated linoleic acid in milk fat . Cheese samples was wrapped in transparent plastic pouches, which have increased the phot-oxidation of lipids. Moreover, packaging materials used for cheese samples have reduced barriers towards light and oxygen which may result the oxidation of cheese. Alves et al.  also find out that Requeija o cremoso cheese get oxidized after exposure to light. It is concluding that cheese may get oxidized during transportation as well as inappropriate storage conditions rather than during modern production system .
At high milling pH protein network is less dense that allows more scattering of light which gives whiter color to cheese while as the milling pH decreased, the protein network becomes more compact and dense, the structure becomes more homogeneous that resist scattering of light and whiteness decreases . The same happened with ripening when the casein network becomes more swollen and decreased light scattering consequently decreased whiteness of cheese. At higher milling pH the cheese were with grainy structure and did not fuse and stretch. However, surface rupture decreases as the milling pH decreases till 4.9 milling pH it is due to increase in elongation and strong casein network but as the storage period increases due to biochemical breakdown of protein network cheese appearance scores reduced as the cheese losses its consistency to stretch but fusion increases . Cheese becomes soft as milling pH reduced due to dissociation of casein network in to smaller aggregates. As the pH drops, the casein integrity also lost . This was probably because of the more compact structure of the cheese as lower pH of cheese curd decreases the electrostatic repulsion and strengthens interactions within and between casein aggregates which result in cluster formation and firmer texture .
Complete information about the fatty acid profile of Mozzarella cheese is the concerning matter of consumer’s health. Fatty acid profile of buffalo mozzarella cheese at various milling pH is demonstrated in this study. Buffalo milk cheese is rich with the saturated fatty acid but also exhibit unsaturated fatty acid that has strong health impact to control cardiovascular diseases and reduce the risk of cancer. It is a confusing nutritional concept among consumers about industrial scale produced cheese as it has less flavor and texture qualities as compared to artisanal cheese. In the present study it is concluded that processing technologies minimally influence the fatty acid profile of cheese rather than post manufacturing conditions. The study showed that unsaturated fatty acids of mozzarella cheese are chemically more sensitive as compared to saturated fatty acids and decreases with the storage of mozzarella cheese if it is not properly packed or stored.
Conjugated Linoleic Acids
Monounsaturated fatty acids
Polyunsaturated fatty acids
Saturated fatty acids
Pariza MW, Park Y, Cook ME. The biological active isomers of conjugated linoleic acid. Prog Lipids Res. 2001;40:283–98.
Banni S, Murru E, Angioni E, Carta G, Melis MP. Conjugated linoleic acid isomers (CLA): good for everything? Sci Aliments. 2002;22:371–80.
Molketin J. Bioactive lipids naturally occurring in bovine milk. Nahrung. 1999;43:185–9.
Zicarelli L. Buffalo milk: its properties, dairy yield and mozzarella production. Vet Res Commun. 2004;1:127–35.
Athar IH, Anwar M. Comparison of mozzarella cheese prepared from buffalo milk by starter culture and direct acidification techniques. Pak J Sci Ind Res. 1996;4(35):108–11.
Mansson HL. Fatty acids in bovine milk fat. Food Nutr Res. 2008;52. https://doi.org/10.3402/fnr.v52i0.1821.
MacGibbon AHK, Taylor MW. Composition and structure of bovine milk lipids. In: Fox PF, McSweeney PLH, editors. Advanced dairy chemistry. New York: Springer; 2006. p. 1–42.
Jensen RG. The composition of bovine Milk lipids: January 1995 to December 2000. J Dairy Sci. 2002;85:295–350.
Nudda A, McGuire MA, Battacone G, Pulina G. Seasonal variation in conjugated linoleic acid and vaccenic acid in milk fat of sheep and its transfer to cheese and ricotta. J Dairy Sci. 2005;88:1311–9.
Ha Y, Grimm NK, Pariza MW. Newly recognized anti-carcinogenic fatty acids: identification and quantification in natural and processed cheeses. J Agri Food Chem. 1989;(1):75–81.
Werner SA, Luedecke LO, Shultz TD. Determination of conjugated linoleic acid content and isomer distribution in three cheddar-type cheeses: effects of cheese cultures, processing, and aging. J Agri Food Chem. 1992;(10):1017–21.
Gnadig S, Chamba JF, Perread E, Chappaz S, Chardigny JM, Rickert R, Steinhart H, Sébédio JL. Influence of manufacturing conditions on the conjugated linoleic acid content and the isomer composition in ripened french emmental cheese. J Dairy Res. 2004;71:367–71.
Steinhart C. Conjugated linoleic acid - the good news about animal fat. J Chem Educ. 1996;73:302–3.
Lin H, Boylston TD, Chang MJ, Luedecke LO, Shultz TD. Survey of the conjugated linoleic acid contents of dairy products. J Dairy Sci. 1995;78:2358–65.
Gursoy O, Seckin AK, Kinik O, Metin M. Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) content of most popular Turkish hard and soft cheeses. Milchwissenschaft. 2003;58:622–3.
Santillo A, Caroprese M, Marino R, d'Angelo F, Sevi A, Albenzio M. Fatty acid profile of milk and Cacioricotta cheese from Italian Simmental cows as affected by dietary flaxseed supplementation. J Dairy Sci. 2016;99:2545–51.
Guinee TP, O’Callaghan DJ. Simple empirical method for objective of the stretchability of cheese on cooked pizza pies. J Food Eng. 1998;31:147–61.
Gulzar N, Aysha S, Nuzhat H, Muhammad S. Influence of mozzarella and semi ripened cheddar cheese amalgamations on the chemical composition and textural attributes of processed pizza cheese. Pak J Agri Sci. 2016;53:209–16.
AOAC. Official method of analysis. Washington, DC: The Association of Official Analytical Chemists. 17th Ed; 2000.
Ong L, Henriksson A, Shah NP. Proteolytic pattern and organic acid profiles of probiotic products. Int Dairy J. 2007;17:67–78.
Marshall RJ. Physicochemical properties accounting for cheese texture. Acta Psychol. 1993;84:69–77.
IDF. Determination of the nitrogen content and calculation of crude protein. Brussels: Int Dairy Federation; 1993.
Kirk RS, Sawyer R. Pearson’s composition and analysis of foods. UK: Longman Scientific and Technical; 1991. p. 537–41.
ISO, International standard. Animal and vegetable fats and oils. Preparation of methyl esters of fatty acids. Geneva: ISO 5509:2000(E), International Organization for Standardization; 2000.
Jo Y, Benoist DM, Ameerally A, Drake MA. Sensory and chemical properties of gouda cheese. J Dairy Sci. 2018;101:1967–89.
Steel RGD, Torrie JH, Dickey DA. Principals and procedures of statistics. A biometerical approach. New York: McGraw Hill Book Co. Inc; 1997.
Guinee TP, Feeney EP, Auty MAE, Fox PF. Effect of pH and calcium concentration on some textural and functional properties of mozzarella cheese. J Dairy Sci. 2002;85:1655–69.
Sert D, Ayar A, Akin N. The effects of starter culture on chemical composition, microbiological and sensory characteristics of Turkish Kasar cheese during ripening. Intl J Dairy Technol. 2007;60:245–52.
Smith R, Alistair JC, Matt G, David R. Mozzarella cheese – a review of the structural development during processing. Food Biophy. 2018;13:1–10.
Paz NF, Enzo GDO, Fernando JV, Margarita A, Adriana NR. Effect of pH at drainage on the physicochemical, textural and microstructural characteristics of mozzarella cheese from goat milk. Food Sci Technol. 2017;37:193–201.
Ahmad S, Nadeem M, Ayaz M, Jaspal MH. Effect of low melting fractions of Milk fat on Lipolysis of Cheddar cheese. J Food Process Preserv. 2015. https://doi.org/10.1111/jfpp.12501.
Batool M, Nadeem M, Imran M, Khan IT, Bhatti JA, Ayaz M. Lipolysis and Antioxidant properties of cow and Buffalo Cheddar cheese in accelerated ripening. Lipids Health Dis. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12944-018-0871-912944-2018-871.
Nadeem M, Mahmud A, Imran M, Khaliuqe A. Enhancement of the oxidative stability of whey butter through almond (Prunus dulcis) Peel extract. J Food Process Preserv. 2015. https://doi.org/10.1111/jfpp.12265.
Alves RMV, Van Dender AGF, Jaime SBM, Moreno I. Stability of ‘ Requeija˜ o cremoso’ in different packages exposed to light. Paris: Poster, Congrilait 2002, 26th International Dairy Conference.
Fletouris DJ, Maria AG, Evropi NB. The influence of retail display storage on the fatty acid composition of modified atmosphere packaged Graviera Agraphon cheese. Intl J Dairy Technol. 2015;68:218–26.
Pastorino AJ, Dave RI, Oberg CJ, McMahon DJ. Temperature effect on structure opacity relationship of non-fat mozzarella cheese. J Dairy Sci. 2002;85:2106–23.
Joshi NS, Mu Hukumarappan K, Dave RI. Effect of calcium on physiochemical properties of fat free mozzarella cheese. J Food Sci. 2004;68:2289–94.
Roginski H, Fuquay J, Fox. Low fat cheese. In: Roginski H, Fuquay J, Fox, editors. Encyclopedia of dairy science. UK: Academic press; 2003. p. 438–44.
Johnson, M. The melt and stretch of cheese. Dairy Pipeline; 2003. https://www.cdr.wisc.edu/sites/default/files/pipelines/2000/pipeline_2000_vol12_01.pdf. Acessed 17 June 2018.
We sincerely thank the University of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, Lahore for providing us with necessary resources and support during research study.
We acknowledged the financial support by Higher Education Commission (HEC), Islamabad-Pakistan to conduct research.
Availability of data and materials
Data of the present study are in the form of Tables.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
We declare that there is no competing interests regarding the publication of this paper.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.